Brendan Nelson says leadership is everything - how does Malcolm Turnbull rate?

There has been a lot of talk about Malcolm Turnbull’s leadership in recent weeks, but little about what political leadership means in operational terms.  Brendan Nelson produced a notable list in an article he penned on August 10 in the SMH: The priorities are party, people and platform with an inspiring vision.  He said “At times like this assertions are made that it is not about leadership and the party should drop its ‘messiah complex’.  Nonsense.  Leadership is everything, whether of a political party, company or school. Vision, inspiration, character, judgment, temperament, humility, intellect and courage are just some of the qualities that will define our party's success.” [more]

So how does Malcolm Turnbull’s leadership rate on Nelson’s criteria: vision, inspiration, character, judgment, temperament, humility, intellect and courage?  Make your own ratings using any scale you wish.

Vision

We know Turnbull has a vision to be PM and to lead the Coalition to victory at the next election, but let’s check his vision for Australia.  I cannot recall reading or hearing a substantial statement from him recently, but from time to time he has embraced the principles of individual freedom, personal initiative, ‘having a go’, entrepreneurship, free markets and small government.  He has consistently maintained that ‘small business is the engine-room of our economy’ and that government should direct its efforts towards supporting small business and making it easier to function.  Early in his parliamentary life he made some suggestions about options for the tax system, much to Peter Costello’s annoyance, and he made statements about climate change and water when he was Minister for the Environment and Water Resources in the Howard Government.

But since becoming Opposition Leader what has he told us about the direction in which our nation should head, where it should be in the decades ahead, economically, geopolitically, regionally, militarily, diplomatically, culturally and ideologically?  What future does he see for manufacturing, small business, resources, agriculture, transport, infrastructure and tourism?  What is his vision for the tax and transfer system, the health care system, federal-state relations, the federation, national security, climate change amelioration, water security, population management, and multiculturalism?  Can any reader refer to a comprehensive statement that encompasses these matters?

Give Turnbull a score on his political vision.

Inspiration

Evidence of Turnbull’s capacity to inspire is fragmentary.  When he first entered the political domain he made a strong impression on many people who soon saw him as a future leader and PM.  He looked impressive, spoke well, sounded convincing, argued soundly and seemed destined for greatness.  His many achievements in journalism, law, business and banking went before him.  Recently his capacity to inspire seems to have deserted him.  His party is fractured, many of his colleagues are doing as they please and sometimes contradict him, and his aura of confidence has been diminished by the OzCar affair.  He tends to be circumlocutory and testy during interviews and has difficulty getting his points across.  Inspirational individuals have the capacity to engage people, convince them, imbue them with enthusiasm and lead them effortlessly.  Even as he tries to inspire, as he’s now attempting with his Frontier Economics plan for an ETS, he is not convincing.  Recent events may have pressed many to tune out; if the people are not listening, inspiring them is impossible.

What is your score for inspiration?

Character

Character is an attribute that although difficult to define, we all understand.  It has been discussed lately in regard to Turnbull’s involvement in the OzCar affair.  ‘Character’ encompasses such attributes as moral or ethical quality, honesty, courage, integrity, keeping promises, loyalty, being reputable, trustworthiness, respect for others, sense of responsibility, self-restraint, justice and fairness, care and concern, civic virtue and citizenship, and always doing ones best.

The Government is mounting a sustained attack on Turnbull’s character in the wake of the OzCar affair, questioning his behaviour in collaborating clandestinely with Godwin Grech to bring down the PM and Treasurer on grounds of corruption and lying to parliament.  More about this is to be revealed.  Does a person of fine character do what Turnbull has done?

What is Turnbull’s character score?

Judgement

This is the area of Turnbull’s makeup that is most questioned contemporaneously.  We all know what judgement is; as good a definition as any is ‘the capacity to assess situations or circumstances shrewdly and to draw sound conclusions’.  That Turnbull accepted the Godwin Grech email without exercising due diligence and went along with Grech’s suggestions about how to bring down the PM and Treasurer, has raised serious questions about his political judgement.

Rate his judgement.

Temperament

‘Temperament’ in a psychological sense has four categories.  The first is the extrovert who is never at a loss for words, confident but often lacking discipline.  The second is the decisive, rational, forceful, strong-willed, determined and independent person who is self-opinionated, practical and makes sound, quick decisions, is not afraid of obstacles and tends to drive right through or over problems, but does not display compassion easily.

The third is the conscientious person who tends to be introverted, is analytical and perfectionist, often moody and depressed, pessimistic, can be legalistic and rigid, and intolerant and impatient with those who do not see things his way.  The fourth category is the idealist - an 'easy going', calm and steady person who is not easily disturbed, makes an good teacher, counsellor and administrator, is very dependable and organized but may lack motivation, drive and ambition.

Turnbull fits the second category best, but with some characteristics of the first.  What is the most suitable temperament for political leadership?

Score him on the suitability of his temperament for leadership.

Humility

We all know what this means, but a good definition is the quality of being courteously respectful of others, willing to acknowledge mistakes and able to apologize. It is the opposite of aggressiveness, arrogance, boastfulness, and vanity.

Rate him on his humility.

Intellect

Intellect or intelligence needs no elaboration except to say that it is not a uniform characteristic.  Political intelligence, nous, wisdom is a trait separate from other forms of intelligence.

Score him on his intellect in a political sense.

Courage

Courage is equated with bravery, strength of will, intrepidity and fortitude, and is the ability to confront fear, pain, risk, danger, uncertainty, or intimidation. Physical courage is courage in the face of physical pain, hardship, or threat of death, while moral courage is the ability to act rightly in the face of popular opposition, shame, scandal, or discouragement.

How do you rate Turnbull’s courage in a political sense? 

You may have other attributes on which you would rate a political leader, but for this exercise let’s use Nelson’s to rate Turnbull’s aptitude to lead the Opposition.  Please share your assessment with us all.

As he wrote out his list, I wonder how Brendan Nelson rated him?

I’m sure you can guess what my assessment is.

Rate This Post

Current rating: NaN / 5 | Rated 0 times

Acerbic Conehead

13/08/2009VISION: he experienced one of the Virgin Mary when he operated a huckster stall at Lourdes INSPIRATION: got it when reading the Merchant Banker of Venice in Year 10 CHARACTER: knew he definitely was one when Wilson Tuckey, upon hearing him waxing lyrical about the ETS, asked, "who the f**k's this character?" JUDGEMENT: where's that AFP report? TEMERAMENT: he has a pathological hatred of the Geelong Football Club HUMILITY: he absolutely adores FIGJAM COURAGE: has lots of this - sits in the same party room as Heffo, Bronny and Iron Bar without demanding a battalion of Irish Guards for protection

janice

14/08/2009Truffles fails miserably so far as having any credentials necessary for the prime ministership of this country is concerned. If he did have any intelligence at all he would have concluded by now that he will never be PM so long as his bum points to the ground and that it is way past time to get himself out of politics.

Sharon

14/08/2009Tara Hack should have put Turnball in her song about Rudd/Howard: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wg5l9J4Qj1k On the other hand, the song probably has a longer shelf life than Turnball.

Kersebleptes

14/08/2009The Prime-ministership was to be a mere stepping stone in Malcolm's progress. He is a republican, remember. The Presidency beckoned enticingly- finally he'd be able to use the Royal 'we" in its proper context. It was just the obvious place for someone of his capabilities (best in country) to go...

Bilko

15/08/2009I have just read Annabel Crabb's col today and the letter from a young lady experience at the hand of "podgy" Turnbull was quite alarming and even more so that Syd Grammar officials seem not to intervene I found more depressing. The home of the upwardly mobile etc. I am sure Turnbull has many happy memories from that experience. So to his qualities VISION: for Aus none himself all self fulfilling INSPIRATION: Whatever pops into his head CHARACTER: Bully, arrogant, full of himself etc etc JUDGEMENT: none TEMERAMENT: hates everyone else HUMILITY: none COURAGE: heaps for all the wrong reasons Summary; perfect for present temporary position

Ad astra reply

16/08/2009Sorry folks for the delay in responding. I’ve been in transit to North Queensland for a few weeks of warmth. Thank you for your amusing contributions. I read the Annabelle Crabb piece Bilko, which shows once again the truth of the old saying – ‘a leopard never changes it spots’. Is Turnbull a ‘leopard’? http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/opinion/when-turnbull-was-a-teen-terror-20090814-el3r.html?page=1

Bilko

16/08/2009from the wild west song by Oscar Brand "the leopard has a spot for every day of the year, yes lady what about leap year,- lift up the leopards tail, now that takes me back a bit. watch out for a turnbull backlash/tailswipe
How many oranges do I have if I have 3 oranges and take ONE away?